Stocks: Buying on Margin

Lately, I have been investing in the stock market and have been doing pretty well. I guess a lot of what the experts said about the stock market snapping back was true cause I have definitely been able to experience a lot of gains since the recent market recovery. Even though I feel like I have been taking steps in the right direction, there is always room for improvement. During a conversation with one of my colleagues, I was asked about "margins", which is something that I have heard of but do not fully understand. Of course, this would be a perfect opportunity to educate myself about this procedure as well as write an article about it.

"Buying on Margin" has a very negative connotation due to the fact that this is a practice that contributed to the Great Depression that occurred during the 1920s. From my understanding, many people took at loans to purchase stocks however, when those stocks did not appreciate, many people were left with loans that they were unable to repay. The following information is quoted directly from Wikipedia:

During the Crash of 1929 preceding the Great Depression, margin requirements were only 10%. Brokerage firms, in other words, would lend $9 for every $1 an investor had deposited. When the market fell, brokers called in these loans, which could not be paid back. Banks began to fail as debtors defaulted on debt and depositors attempted to withdraw their deposits en masse, triggering multiplebank runs. Government guarantees and Federal Reserve banking regulations to prevent such panics were ineffective or not used. Bank failures led to the loss of billions of dollars in assets. Outstanding debts became heavier, because prices and incomes fell by 20–50% but the debts remained at the same dollar amount. After the panic of 1929, and during the first 10 months of 1930, 744 US banks failed. (In all, 9,000 banks failed during the 1930s). By April 1933, around $7 billion in deposits had been frozen in failed banks or those left unlicensed after the March Bank Holiday.

As with most things, when there is an unclear understanding of how something works, it is very easy for something that is supposed to be used for positive to turn negative. However, after doing some research, the whole idea of buying on margin is not nearly as complicated.

The terms "buying on margin" basically means to borrow money from a broker to buy stock. The money that is being borrowed is not a conventional loan that you can obtain from a bank. It has a lot more regulations and guidelines that have been implemented to try to help prevent a repeat of the "Great Depression". Below are some of the highlights for a margin account:

1. Typically requires a minimum investment of $2000.
2. Usually requires a set margin maintenance fee (used to insure there is enough "cushion" in the event of loss in stock value)
3. Allows you to borrow up to 50% of the purchase price of a stock.
4. This account typically carries an interest rate imposed by the broker on borrowed funds.
5. Penny stocks, OTCBB (Over-the-counter bulletin board) and IPO (Initial Public Offering) stocks do not qualify for margin purchases.

With all of these requirements, it is hard to see the benefits of having a margin account. However, the example below can illustrate why this account has the potential to return great rewards:

Let's assume that you have $5000 in your cash account. You want to purchase a stock that is worth $10 and you believe that it will double in the matter of a year. Instead of limiting yourself to $5000, because you have a margin account, you can purchase $10000 worth of the stock (borrowing up to 50% [maximum] of the purchase price of the stock). In a year, the stock ends up doubling from $10 to $20 and you decide to sell the stock. So the value of the amount of stock you own goes from $10000 to $20000, however, you have to pay back $5000 + interest which is the based on the original amount that you owned. For our example, let's assume that there is 0% interest, resulting in a net profit of $10000.

If you had just used a regular cash account, your profit would have only been $5000.

Margin Account:

Initial Cash Investment: $5000

Amount Borrowed: $5000

Initial Investment Amount: $10000

Final Investment Amount: $20000

Net Profit (Final Investment - Amount borrowed - Initial Cash Investment) = $10000

Cash Account:

Initial Cash Investment: $5000

Amount Borrowed: $0

Initial Investment Amount: $5000

Final Investment Amount: $10000

Net Profit (Final Investment - Amount borrowed - Initial Cash Investment) = $5000

As you can see from the above example, it seems like a really good idea to proceed with investing using margins due to the fact that the return on investment is double of what it is by using cash alone. However, it would be irresponsible to just provide the possible benefit of the accounts without discussing the cons of this type of account.

In the case that your thoughts were incorrect about the particular stock in the previous example and instead of the stock doubling in value, it was halved, things change drastically. Let's review the previous example using these new numbers:

Margin Account:

Initial Cash Investment: $5000

Amount Borrowed: $5000

Initial Investment Amount: $10000

Final Investment Amount: $5000

Net Change (Final Investment - Amount borrowed - Initial Cash Investment) = $-5000

Cash Account:

Initial Cash Investment: $5000

Amount Borrowed: $0

Initial Investment Amount: $5000

Final Investment Amount: $2500

Net Change (Final Investment - Amount borrowed - Initial Cash Investment) = -$2500

As you can see, in addition to the potential for growing your profits exponetitally, you also expose yourself to the potential to grow your losses in the same manner. One more important thing about margin accounts is that the broker reserves to the right to issue a margin call in the event that the value of the stocks has decreased below the threshold of the margin maintenance fee. Since the stocks that are purchased are held as collateral by the broker, they can force the investor to prematurely sell these stocks in the event that the investor's account goes below a certain amount.

An example of this is the following:

Initial Cash Investment: $5000

Amount Borrowed: $5000

Initial Investment Amount: $10000

Margin Maintenance Fee: 25%

Final Investment Amount: $7500

Actual Margin Funds: $2500

Marginal Funds Required in the account: $1875

With the stock price being reduced to $7500, the investor is required to have at least 25% of margin equity in the account. So, the investor is required to have 25% * 7500 of margin money in the account, that amount is $1875. The broker would not issue a maintenance call on this money due to the fact that there is $2500 of margin money in the account exceeding the required amount of $1875.

If the margin maintenance fee was increased to 40%, the marginal files required for the account would be increased substantially. See below for the new requirements:

Initial Cash Investment: $5000

Amount Borrowed: $5000

Initial Investment Amount: $10000

Margin Maintenance Fee: 40%

Final Investment Amount: $7500

Actual Margin Funds: $2500

Marginal Funds Required in the account: $3000

As you can see, the broke would initiate a margin call this margin account to make sure that there is coverage for the amount of money borrowed. This will either result in the investor depositing more money into the account to cover for the call or if the investor does not have the money to the deposit, will result in the broker selling the stocks (investor's permission may not be required).

This defeats the "buy and hold" strategy to attempt to wait out negative swings in stock as the investor may be forced to sell their stock prematurely.

Although this is an advanced topic, it is good to have a bit of an idea of some of the tools that are available to enable you to obtain financial freedom quicker. Please let me know your comments about buying on margin and some of the experiences you have had with "buying on margin".

Stay Disciplined!